Despite using identical question papers across nine general education boards, this year’s HSC results showed a gap of nearly 17 percentage points between the highest and lowest pass rates, raising questions about examination standards and answer script evaluation.
The Higher Secondary Certificate (HSC) examination results have revealed a significant difference in pass rates among Bangladesh’s nine general education boards, despite students answering identical question papers.
The Dhaka Education Board recorded a pass rate of 61.80 per cent, while the Barishal Education Board recorded 44.84 per cent. The difference between the two boards was nearly 17 percentage points.
The results have raised an important question: Why do pass rates differ so much when students sit for examinations using the same questions?
There is no single explanation for this difference. Students’ preparation, teaching quality, teacher shortages and unequal learning opportunities may all affect examination results. Weak performance in English and Information and Communication Technology (ICT) also affected the overall results this year.
However, the differences cannot be explained by students’ preparation alone. Examination centre management, invigilation standards and answer script evaluation also need careful examination.
Are Examination Environments the Same Across All Boards?
Although students received identical question papers, their examination environments may not have been the same. The standard of supervision and monitoring can vary between examination centres.
If some centres maintain strict monitoring while others follow comparatively relaxed practices, students may face different examination conditions. Such differences could directly or indirectly affect their performance.
Therefore, authorities need to examine whether examination centre management and invigilators’ performance are consistent across all education boards.
Differences in Answer Script Evaluation Need Attention
Another important issue is whether all education boards follow the same standards when evaluating answer scripts.
Identical question papers can help assess students against a common standard. However, this purpose may be affected if examiners apply different marking standards to similar answers.
For example, one examiner may award higher marks for an answer, while another may give fewer marks for the same response. In such cases, students’ results could depend partly on the examiner’s approach.
This makes it necessary to review the answer script evaluation system alongside the board-wise results.
Inter-Board Evaluation Could Be Introduced on a Trial Basis
One possible way to examine differences in marking standards is to introduce an inter-board answer script evaluation system.
Under this approach, examiners from one education board would evaluate selected answer scripts from another board. For example, some Dhaka Board scripts could be assigned to examiners from other boards. Similarly, selected scripts from the Jashore Board could be evaluated by examiners outside that board.
The system does not need to be introduced nationwide at once. Education authorities could first select a limited number of answer scripts for trial evaluation.
They could then compare the marks awarded under the existing system with those given through inter-board evaluation. This would help identify whether any board follows comparatively strict or lenient marking practices.
Such a trial could also improve accountability among examiners and education boards. However, inter-board evaluation alone would not ensure fairness.
A Uniform Marking System Is Also Necessary
A reliable evaluation system requires clear and consistent marking guidelines. Examiners should receive proper training and follow the same assessment criteria.
Authorities should also prepare sample answers showing different acceptable ways of answering a question. This is particularly important for questions that allow more than one correct response.
In addition, a selected number of answer scripts could be checked by a second examiner. Authorities could compare the marks awarded by both examiners to identify major differences.
If substantial differences emerge, a third examiner could review the scripts. Regular checks of this kind would help maintain consistency and reduce the influence of personal marking preferences.
Board-Wise Results Need Deeper Analysis
Simply comparing pass rates does not provide a complete picture of students’ performance. Education authorities need a more detailed analysis of the results.
They should examine subject-wise failure rates, commonly incorrect answers and the distribution of marks for individual questions. Differences in marks awarded by examiners should also receive attention.
At the same time, authorities need information about examination centre management, invigilation and the overall examination environment across different boards.
This information could help identify the main reasons behind differences in results. It would also provide a stronger basis for future improvements in the examination system.
Improving Education Requires Shared Responsibility
The responsibility for improving examination results does not rest with education boards alone. Teachers, students and parents also have important roles to play.
Teachers should focus on students’ actual understanding rather than examination preparation based mainly on memorisation. Students need to develop the ability to explain subjects and answer questions using their own knowledge.
Parents should also look beyond GPA and pass rates when assessing their children’s education. They need to understand what their children have learned and identify the subjects where they need additional support.
Similarly, examiners must follow established marking criteria rather than personal opinions or individual preferences.
High Pass Rates Do Not Always Mean Better Education
A low pass rate does not automatically mean that an education system is poor. Likewise, a high pass rate does not necessarily prove that the system is performing well.
The more important issue is whether students receive a fair assessment of their knowledge and skills. Examination results should reflect what students have genuinely learned.
If identical question papers are the first step towards establishing a common national examination standard, consistent answer script evaluation should be the next priority.
This year’s HSC results should therefore encourage a wider review of the examination and evaluation systems. Education authorities need to examine not only how many students passed, but also whether every student received a fair and consistent assessment.
When students across Bangladesh answer identical examination questions, the standards used to evaluate their answers should also be as consistent as possible.






